Carlo's Pizza Shirley

View on UberEats

4.7

(93 reviews)

Italian

Pizza

Pasta

Address

451 Glen Drive

Shirley, NY 11967

Phone

+16319248760

Opening Hours

Sunday

11:30 - 21:40

Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday

10:30 - 21:40

Friday

10:30 - 23:40

Saturday

10:30 - 22:40

Menu of Carlo's Pizza Shirley at Shirley, NY

Appetizers

Rice Ball

$5.40

Filled with Meat, Peas, Onions and Cheese.

Wings

$8.50

Choose Your Size and Sauce.

Mozzarella Sticks

$8.35

Served with marinara sauce.

Chicken Fingers (12)

$10.25

Comes with a Side of Honey Mustard.

Baked Ziti Balls (4)

$10.75

Breaded and Fried Baked Ziti Covered in Vodka Sauce.

Cheesy Garlic Bread

$4.25

Freshly baked bread smothered in melted cheese and garlic.

Meatballs (2)

$4.80

Served with our Original Tomato Sauce.

Breaded Ravioli

$8.40

Crispy breaded pasta pockets served as an appetizer.

Fried Calamari

$11.05

Battered & Deep Fried, Served with Marinara Sauce.

Zucchini Sticks

$7.15

Fresh Zucchini Sliced, Breaded & Fried to a Golden Brown & Served with Marinara Sauce.

Hot Antipasto

$13.25

Stuffed Mushrooms, Baked Clams, Fried Calamari and Eggplant Rollatini.

Baked Clams

$9.55

Seasoned with Bread Crumbs, Garlic & Olive Oil.

Broccoli Rabe

$10.75

Sauteed with Sweet Italian Sausage in Garlic & Oil.

French Fries

$3.60

Crispy potato sticks served hot.

Onion Rings

$3.60

Crispy onion slices served as a tasty appetizer.

Stuffed Mushrooms

$9.55

Seasoned and Stuffed with Crab Meat Topped with Mozzarella Cheese.

Pepper Stuffed Garlic Knot

$1.95

Soft, buttery garlic knots filled with a peppery surprise.

Tomato Stuffed Garlic Knot

$1.95

Soft, buttery garlic knots filled with fresh tomato.

Garlic Bread

$2.70

Freshly baked bread infused with garlic.

Clams Casino

$10.75

Seasoned with Bell Peppers, Bacon, Garlic & Bread Crumbs.

Mac & Cheese

$8.50

Creamy pasta dish with a rich, cheesy flavor.

Mussels Marinara

$10.75

Sauteed in Garlic then Simmered in our Original Tomato Sauce.

Bianco

$10.75

Mussels served in your choice of sauce over pasta.

Gluten Free Mozzarella Stick

$8.00

Crisp mozzarella sticks, perfect for a satisfying start.

Panini

$9.00

Grilled bread filled with savory ingredients.

Gluten Free Mozzarella Sticks

$10.75

Crispy mozzarella sticks, perfect for a gluten-free snack.

Beverages

Pepsi (2 Liter)

$4.50

Refreshing beverage perfect for any occasion.

Pepsi (20 Oz)

$3.40

Refreshing drink to quench your thirst.

Diet Coke (2 Liter)

$4.50

Refreshing beverage perfect for any occasion.

Diet Coke (20 Oz)

$3.40

Crisp, refreshing cola beverage.

Root Beer (20 Oz)

$3.40

Classic American root beer, crisp and refreshing.

Sprite (20 Oz)

$3.40

Fresh, crisp, and refreshing soda.

Chicken

Chicken Mediterranean

$23.40

Chicken, Eggplant, Diced Tomatoes & Zucchini Sauteed in Chunk Tomato and Wine Sauce, Topped with Mozzarella.

Chicken Parmigiana

$22.80

Chicken Delicately Sauteed and Covered with Mozzarella, Topped with our Original Tomato Sauce.

Chicken Scaprella

$22.80

Chicken Breast and Sweet Italian Sausage Delicately Sauteed with a Lemon & Garlic & Wine Sauce.

Chicken Francese

$24.00

Chicken Breast Dipped in Egg Batter and Sauteed in a Wine and Lemon Sauce.

Chicken Rollatini

$22.80

Breast of Chicken Rolled with Cheese, Ham & Assorted Seasonings, Cooked in a Delicate Wine Sauce and Mushrooms.

Chicken Sorrentino

$22.80

Chicken Sauteed in White Wine Topped with Prosciutto, Sliced Tomato and Mozzarella.

Chicken Marsala

$24.00

Chicken Sauteed with Mushrooms in a Marsala wine Sauce and Prosciutto.

Chicken Piccata

$22.80

Chicken Breast Delicately Sauteed with White Wine, Lemon & Artichoke Hearts.

Chicken Cacciatore

$22.80

Chicken Breast Cooked with Onions, and Peppers, Sauteed in a Plum Tomato Sauce and a Splash of Wine.

Children’s Menu

Ravioli (Cheese)

$11.95

Tender cheese filled pasta.

Spaghetti & Meatball (1)

$11.95

Tender spaghetti served with meatballs.

Spaghetti & Marinara Sauce

$9.55

Topped with our Original Tomato Sauce.

Chicken Fingers with French Fries

$11.95

Tender chicken strips served with crispy French fries.

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana with Pasta

$13.00

Breaded and topped with melted mozzarella, served with pasta.

Baked Ziti

$11.95

Classic Italian-style pasta dish with ziti noodles.

Desserts

Cheese Cake

$4.50

Rich and creamy dessert with a velvety texture.

Cannoli

$3.25

Crisp, fried pastry shells filled with sweet ricotta cheese.

Rainbow Cookie

$4.50

Colorful cookie with a sweet surprise.

Hot Heros

Chicken Parm Hero

$12.50

Breaded and topped with melted mozzarella cheese.

Meatball Parmigiana

$9.60

Tender meatballs topped with melted mozzarella cheese and marinara sauce.

Eggplant Parmigiana

$10.80

Breaded Eggplant with Tomato Sauce and Covered in Mozzarella Cheese.

Chicken Bacon Ranch

$12.50

Tender chicken, crispy bacon, and creamy ranch come together in a flavorful hero.

Shrimp Parmigiana

$12.60

Shrimp breaded, topped with mozzarella cheese with our original tomato sauce.

Italian Cold Cuts Hero

$11.40

Thinly sliced meats served on a hero roll.

Sausage & Peppers

$11.15

Savory sausage paired with peppers.

Potatoes & Eggs

$9.30

Potatoes and eggs, a classic combination.

Chicken Francaise Parmigiana

$12.70

Tender chicken topped with melted Parmigiana cheese.

Meatball

$9.30

Juicy meat served in a hero sandwich.

Veal Cutlet Parmigiana

$11.70

Breaded and topped with melted mozzarella cheese.

Buffalo Chicken Parmigiana

$12.50

Crispy chicken topped with melted mozzarella and tangy buffalo sauce.

Sausage Parmigiana

$11.15

Savory sausage topped with melted mozzarella cheese.

Sausage

$9.90

Juicy sausage served hot.

Broccoli Rabe Parmigiana

$10.90

With Chicken or Sausage.

Chicken & Roasted Peppers

$12.50

Tender chicken paired with roasted peppers.

Chicken Club

$12.00

Tender chicken, crispy bacon, and fresh lettuce on toasted bread.

Chicken Marsala Parmigiana

$12.75

Tender chicken topped with Marsala and melted Parmesan cheese.

Peppers & Eggs

$9.95

Scrambled eggs with sautéed peppers.

Sausage & Egg

$11.25

Savory sausage paired with a fried egg.

Sausage & Meatball Parmigiana

$11.00

Savory sausage and meatballs topped with melted mozzarella cheese.

Steak & Cheese

$11.25

Tender steak paired with melted cheese.

Veal & Mushroom Parmigiana

$11.60

Tender veal and sautéed mushrooms in a rich parmesan sauce.

Veal & Pepper Parmigiana

$11.60

Tender veal and peppers in a rich parmesan sauce.

Sausage & Potatoes

$9.50

Savory sausage paired with potatoes.

Veal & Mushroom

$10.40

Tender veal and sautéed mushrooms in a savory hero.

Meatballs & Peppers

$9.55

Tender meatballs paired with sautéed peppers.

Veal & Peppers

$10.40

Tender veal paired with sautéed peppers.

Paninis

Blackened Chicken Panini

$9.00

Side of Tomato, Vodka or Alfredo Sauce.

Chicken with Roasted Red Pepper Panini

$9.00

Side of Tomato, Vodka or Alfredo Sauce.

Chicken, Lettuce and Tomato Panini

$9.00

Side of Tomato, Vodka or Alfredo Sauce.

Eggplant with Roasted Red Pepper Panini

$9.00

Side of Tomato, Vodka or Alfredo Sauce.

Pasta Dishes

Penne Ala Vodka

$19.00

Penne Pasta in a Pink Creamy Vodka Sauce with Red Onions and Ham.

Ravioli Parmigiana

$17.50

Stuffed with Cheese.

Rigatoni with Meat Sauce

$18.30

Topped with our Original Tomato Sauce with Chunks of Ground Beef.

Baked Ziti

$16.75

Tubular pasta baked with rich flavors.

Tortellini with Alfredo Sauce

$16.75

Topped with our Original White Cream Sauce.

Penne Alfredo with Chicken

$21.60

Pasta in a Creamy Alfredo Sauce with Sauteed Chicken Breast, Fresh Tomato and Peas.

Manicotti (Home-Made)

$15.55

Tubular pasta filled with a rich and creamy filling.

Pasta with Meatballs

$15.60

Linguini Pasta, Topped with our Original Tomato Sauce.

Lobster Ravioli

$22.75

Choice of Alfredo, Vodka or Marinara Parmigiana.

Stuffed Shells Parmigiana (Home-Made)

$17.50

Homemade.

Fettuccine Alfredo

$16.80

Fettuccine Pasta in a Creamy Alfredo Sauce.

Lasagna (Home-Made)

$16.75

Layered pasta with rich flavors.

Penne with Sausage

$15.75

Savoury sausage and penne pasta combine for a satisfying meal.

Spaghetti with Marinara

$13.20

Topped with our Original Tomato Sauce.

Pasta with Sausage

$15.60

Linguini Pasta, Topped with our Original Tomato Sauce.

Tortellini with Marinara Sauce

$16.75

Topped with our Original Tomato Sauce.

Linguini with White Clam Sauce

$18.00

Freshly cooked linguini tossed in a rich white clam sauce.

Spaghetti with Broccoli

$15.60

Sauteed with Garlic and Oil.

Linguini with Red Clam Sauce

$18.00

Freshly cooked linguini tossed in a rich red clam sauce.

Pizza

Neapolitan (Large)

$21.00

Classic Neapolitan-style pizza with a thin crust and flavorful toppings.

Neapolitan (Small)

$17.70

Classic Neapolitan-style pizza, small in size.

Deep Dish

$25.80

Round Sicilian. No Toppings.

Cauliflour Crust Pizza

$21.75

Cauliflower-based crust topped with flavorful ingredients.

Sicilian (12 Slices)

$24.30

12 slices.

Gluten Free Pizza

$21.75

Made with a gluten-free crust, perfect for those with dietary restrictions.

Rolls & Calzones

Chicken Roll

$9.60

Tender chicken wrapped in a crispy roll.

Calzone

$7.20

With our Original Tomato Sauce.

Calzone with Ham

$8.40

W/ham & sauce.

Eggplant Tower

$8.80

Eggplant layered with flavorful ingredients.

Garlic Knots (Dozen)

$6.50

Soft, buttery knots infused with a savory garlic flavor.

Zeppoli (Dozen)

$6.00

Light and airy Italian doughnuts, typically powdered with sugar.

Pepperoni Wheel

$3.85

Savory wheel filled with pepperoni.

Deep Fried Calzone

$8.40

Crispy folded dough filled with savory ingredients.

Sausage Roll

$7.50

Savory sausage wrapped in a flaky pastry.

Spinach Wheel

$3.85

Spinach filled pastry wheel.

Stuffed Garlic Knots

$2.50

Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato and Prosciutto.

Seafood

Seafood Ala Vodka

$24.00

Shrimp and Scallops Sauteed with Spinach in a Cream Vodka Sauce.

Calamari Scungilli Combo

$19.25

Squid rings and scungilli, a seafood combination.

Mussels Marinara

$19.15

Sauteed in garlic then simmered in our original tomato sauce.

Seafood Fra Diavolo

$26.50

Spicy seafood dish with shrimp, scallops, and mussels in a flavorful tomato sauce.

Bianco

$16.95

Mussels served in your choice of sauce over pasta.

Scungilli Marinara

$19.15

Fresh Squid or Conch Sauteed in our Marinara Sauce, Served Over Pasta.

Pescatore

$22.75

Shrimp, Calamari, Clams & Mussels in a Light Marinara Sauce Served Over Pasta.

Zuppa De Pesce

$33.55

Shrimp, Scungilli, Calamari, Clams, Mussels & Lobster Cooked Together in a Spicy, Light Marinara Sauce, Served Over Pasta.

Seafood Fra Diavolo Alla Carlo

$26.35

Shrimp in a Spicy Marinara Sauce Served with Mussels & Clams Over Pasta.

Seafood Scampi Combo

$26.35

Shrimp, and Lobster Tail, Sauteed in Butter, Garlic & White Wine.

Calamari

$19.15

Fresh Squid Sauteed in our Marinara Sauce and Served Over Pasta.

Seafood Terrano

$26.35

Lobster Tail & Shrimp Sauteed in a Marinara Sauce Over Pasta.

Shrimp

Shrimp Scampi

$25.15

Shrimp in Garlic, Butter & Wine Sauce.

Shrimp Parmigiana

$25.15

Shrimp Breaded, Topped with Mozzarella Cheese with our Original Tomato Sauce.

Shrimp Alfredo

$25.15

Shrimp Sauteed in a Creamy Alfredo Sauce.

Shrimp Farfale

$25.15

Shrimp with Garlic, Broccoli Rabe & Sun-Dried Tomatoes and Sauteed in Olive Oil & White Wine, Served over Bow-Tie Pasta.

Shrimp Oreganata

$25.15

Shrimp Topped with Seasoned Bread Crumbs in a Light Sauce of Butter, Garlic & White Wine.

Shrimp with Garlic & Oil

$25.15

Shrimp Sauteed and Seasoned in Garlic & Oil Sauce.

Shrimp Fra Diavolo

$21.55

Shrimp in a Spicy Marinara Sauce.

Shrimp Marinara

$25.15

Shrimp Sauteed in our Original Tomato Sauce.

Shrimp Piccata

$25.15

Shrimp Sauteed with Artichoke Hearts with White Wine Lemon and Butter.

Shrimp in Pesto

$25.15

Shrimp Sauteed in a Creamy Pesto Sauce.

Slices

Salad Slice

$7.25

With Chicken.

Regular Slice

$3.75

Classic slice of pizza

Grandma Slice

$3.90

Classic slice of pizza

Chicken Francese Slice

$5.25

Tender chicken in a rich and creamy sauce.

Sicilian Slice

$3.55

Thinly sliced pizza with a rich flavor.

Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice

$5.25

Tender chicken, crispy bacon, and creamy ranch on a slice of pizza.

Pepperoni Slice

$4.25

Thinly sliced pepperoni on a crispy crust.

White Slice

$5.30

Classic slice of pizza

Chicken Marsala

$7.00

Chicken sauteed with mushrooms in a marsala wine sauce and prosciutto.

Stuffed Meat Slice

$6.90

Tender meat slice filled with savory ingredients.

Deep Dish Slice

$4.25

Thick, cheesy slice of classic pizza.

Stuffed Veggie

$6.90

Veggie delight with a savory twist.

Meatball Slice

$4.00

Juicy meatballs on a slice of pizza.

Chicken Chipotle Ranch Slice

$5.25

Spicy chicken slice with a tangy ranch twist.

Chicken Broccoli & Tomato Slice

$5.25

Tender chicken, broccoli, and tomato on a slice.

Eggplant Ricotta Slice

$5.25

Rich eggplant and creamy ricotta cheese in every bite.

Greek Salad Slice

$6.75

Fresh mix of tomatoes, cucumbers, and feta cheese.

Philly Cheese Steak Slice

$5.25

Thinly sliced steak and melted cheese on a toasted bread.

Sausage Slice

$4.00

Savory sausage slice.

Thick Margarita Slice

$5.25

Rich and creamy slice with a tangy twist.

Tomato & Pesto Slice

$5.25

Fresh tomato and pesto on a slice of pizza.

Salad Slice with Grilled Chicken

$8.35

Grilled chicken on a bed of fresh greens.

Broccoli Rabe Slice

$5.25

Broccoli rabe on a slice of pizza.

Pineapple & Ham Slice

$5.25

Sweet and savory combination of pineapple and ham on a slice.

Soups & Salads

Caesar Salad

$10.20

Romaine Lettuce Grated Romano Cheese and Cherry Tomatoes.

Chicken Soup (Quart)

$12.95

Hearty soup made with chicken.

Chicken Bacon Cheddar Salad

$11.35

Lettuce, Tomato, Bacon, Onion, Cheddar, Cucumber & Crispy Chicken.

Lentil (Pint)

$8.00

Hearty, comforting lentil soup.

Pasta Fagioli (Pint)

$8.00

Hearty Italian-style soup made with pasta and beans.

Seafood Bisque (Pint)

$9.00

Rich and flavorful soup made with seafood.

Italian Wedding

$9.00

A classic Italian-inspired salad with a medley of ingredients.

Tossed Garden Salad

$9.55

Lettuce, Tomato, Onions, Cucumbers, and Olives.

Chicken Soup (Pint)

$8.00

Hearty soup made with chicken.

Greek Salad

$11.35

Lettuce, Tomato, Onions, Olives, Carrots, Cucumbers, Red Cabbage and Fresh Feta Cheese.

Tossed Salad (Small)

$7.25

Lettuce, Tomato, Onions, Cucumbers, and Olives.

Antipasto Salad (Boars Head)

$12.60

Ham, Salami, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Carrots Cauliflower, Peppers, and Olives.

Caesar Salad (Small)

$8.35

Romaine Lettuce Grated Romano Cheese and Cherry Tomatoes.

Italian Chef Salad

$10.75

Romaine Lettuce, Salami, Provolone, Pepperoni, Roasted Peppers, Olives & Capers.

Greek Salad (Small)

$8.35

Lettuce, Tomato, Onions, Olives, Carrots, Cucumbers, Red Cabbage and Fresh Feta Cheese.

Chicken Bacon Cheddar Salad (Small)

$9.60

Crisp mixed greens topped with chicken, crispy bacon, and cheddar cheese.

Italian Chef Salad (Small)

$8.35

Fresh mix of greens, Italian meats, and cheeses.

Pasta Fagioli (Quart)

$12.95

Hearty Italian-style soup made with pasta and beans.

Lentil Soup (Quart)

$12.95

Hearty, comforting soup made with lentils.

Seafood Bisque (Quart)

$13.95

Rich and flavorful soup made with seafood.

Fresh Mozzarella Tomato & Basil

$11.95

In Olive Oil.

Scungill Salad

$13.15

Tender Scungilli on a Bed of Lettuce Decorated with Celery, Olives and Tomatoes Served Cold.

Calamari Salad

$13.15

Romaine Lettuce, Grated Romano Cheese, Cherry Tomatoes.

Specialty Pies

Grandma Pizza

$18.50

Classic Italian-style pizza with rich flavors and a crispy crust.

Chicken Bacon Ranch (Large)

$33.75

Tender chicken, crispy bacon, and creamy ranch sauce on a large pie.

Thin Margarita

$23.75

Thin crust pizza with a tangy twist.

White Pie (Large)

$25.25

Rich and creamy pie with a delicate crust.

BBQ Chicken (Large)

$31.95

Tender chicken smothered in BBQ sauce.

Buffalo Chicken (Large)

$30.75

Spicy chicken and buffalo sauce on a large pie.

Stuffed Pizza (Large)

$34.35

Meat or Veg.

Chicken Parm (Large)

$30.75

Breaded and topped with melted mozzarella cheese.

Baked Ziti (Large)

$29.50

Tubular pasta baked with rich flavors.

Special

$26.70

Specialty pie with a unique blend of flavors.

Philly Cheese Steak

$20.75

Thinly sliced steak and melted cheese.

Greek Salad

$28.50

Lettuce Tomato Onions Olives Carrots Cucumbers Red Cabbage and Fresh Feta Cheese.

Capressi

$26.70

Fresh goat cheese, capers, and sun-dried tomatoes on a bed of mixed greens.

Salad Pie

$28.50

Fresh mix of greens in a savory pie crust.

Shrimp

$27.30

Succulent shrimp on a bed of flavorful sauce.

Veggie Special

$26.75

Veggie lovers' delight, featuring a medley of fresh vegetables.

Veal

Veal Francaise

$23.95

Veal Dipped in Egg-Batter and Sauteed in a Wine and Lemon Sauce.

Veal Marsala

$23.95

Veal Sauteed with Mushrooms in a Marsala Wine Sauce and Prosciutto.

Veal Piccata

$23.95

Veal Delicately Sauteed with White Wine, Lemon & Artichoke Hearts.

Veal Rollatini

$23.95

Veal Cutlet Rolled with Cheese, Ham, Seasonings Cooked in a Delicate Wine Sauce and Mushrooms.

Veal Cacciatore

$23.95

Veal Cooked with Onions, Mushrooms and Pepper Sauteed with Plum Tomatoes and a Splash of Wine.

Veal Parmigiana

$23.95

Veal Sauteed with & Covered with Mozzarella Topped with our Original Tomato Sauce.

Veal Sorrentino

$23.95

Veal Sauteed in White Wine Topped with Prosciutto, Sliced Tomato and Mozzarella.