Menu of Carvel Ice Cream (25 N Main St) at
Sayville, NY
Celebration Cakes
Small Square Cake
$27.99
Square Ice cream cakes perfect for any occasion made with layers of freshly made, premium vanilla and chocolate soft serve ice cream, separated by a layer of our famously delicious chocolate crunchies. Feeds 4-6
Round Ice Cream Cake
$42.99
Round ice cream cakes perfect for any occasion made with layers of freshly made, premium vanilla and chocolate soft serve ice cream, separated by a layer of our famously delicious chocolate crunchies. Variety of sizes that serve 10-16 people
Sheet Ice Cream Cake
$46.99
Sheet ice cream cakes perfect for any occasion made with layers of freshly made, premium vanilla and chocolate soft serve ice cream, separated by a layer of our famously delicious chocolate crunchies. Variety of sizes that serve 14-40 people
Fudgie the Whale®
$45.99
Our famous whale of a cake with layers of vanilla and chocolate ice cream, separated by a layer of chocolate crunchies then covered with fudge, crunchies and whipped topping. Variety of sizes that serve 6-12 people
Standard Candles
$2.99
24 candles to blow out. Wish not included.
*candle style may vary
Cup of Toppings
$4.59
Your choice of extra toppings.
Dashers
Reese’s ® Peanut Butter Sundae Dasher®
$9.99
Layers of Reese's® Peanut Butter Cups, Reese's® Peanut Butter Sauce, vanilla ice cream and fudge topped with whipped cream and fudge drizzle.
Mint Chocolate Chip Sundae Dasher®
$9.99
Layers of chocolate crunchies, mint ice cream and fudge topped with whipped cream and fudge drizzle.
Fudge Brownie Sundae Dasher®
$8.99
Layers of fudge brownie bites, vanilla ice cream and hot fudge topped with whipped cream and fudge drizzle.
Heath® Sundae Dasher®
$9.99
Layers of Heath® pieces, vanilla ice cream and caramel topped with whipped cream and caramel drizzle.
Strawberry Shortcake Sundae Dasher®
$9.99
Layers of vanilla ice cream, strawberries and pound cake topped with whipped cream and strawberry drizzle.
OREO® Cookie Sundae Dasher®
$9.99
Layers of Oreo® cookies, vanilla ice cream and fudge topped with whipped cream and fudge drizzle.
Dessert Packs
Ice Cream Quart
$16.99
Your choice of ice cream flavor in a quart.
Flying Saucers®
$15.99
Soft ice cream sandwiched between two Flying Saucer® chocolate wafers
Sprinkle Cups
$16.99
Vanilla or chocolate ice cream with sprinkles served with a cherry on top.
Cup of Toppings
$4.59
Your choice of extra toppings.
Deluxe Flying Saucers®
$16.99
Soft ice cream rolled in sprinkles and sandwiched between two Flying Saucer® chocolate wafers.
Chipsters
$16.99
Soft serve vanilla ice cream sandwiched between two chocolate chip cookies.
Holiday Cake
Cookie O'Puss (One-size)
$33.99
Celebrate St. Patrick's Day with the cake that has everything on it. Straight from the party planet it's Cookie O'Puss.
Ice Cream & Sorbet
Soft Serve Ice Cream
$6.79
Our classic soft ice cream available in a variety of flavors
Scooped Ice Cream
$6.79
Classic scooped ice cream in a variety of flavors
Cup of Toppings
$4.59
Your choice of extra toppings.
Limited Time Offer
Biscoff® Cookie Soft Serve
$5.86
Delicious caramelized Biscoff® cookies swirled smoothly in The Original Soft Serve ™.
Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Biscoff® Cookie Scooped
$5.86
A scrumptious scoop of ice cream featuring swirls of caramel and Biscoff® Carvel Crunchies™.
Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Biscoff® Cookie Shake
$8.08
Biscoff® Cookie ice cream blissfully blended with Biscoff® Carvel Crunchies™ hand-spun in a shake.
Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Biscoff® Cookie Sundae Dasher®
$8.08
Biscoff® Cookie Soft Serve Ice Cream layered with Biscoff® Carvel Crunchies™ , and caramel swirls topped with whipped cream.
Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Biscoff® Cookie Flying Saucer® (Deluxe)
$3.58
Biscoff® Cookie soft serve sandwiched between our classic Flying Saucer® chocolate wafers, all rolled in Biscoff® Carvel Crunchies™.
Product contains milk, soy, wheat.
Biscoff® Carvel Crunchies™
$1.09
Vanilla Carvel Crunchies™ tossed in a white bonnet hard shell and mixed with Biscoff® Cookie crumbles.
Product contains soy, wheat.
Shake & Carvelanche
Shakes
$8.99
Hand-spun shakes made with our signature soft serve ice cream
Carvelanche
$9.99
Our signature soft ice cream with your choice of mix-ins. Best enjoyed with a spoon
Sundaes
Classic Sundae
$7.99
Your choice of soft ice cream, one topping, whipped cream and a cherry.
