Perfect for the fall and holidays, this cheese has the taste of apple pie and cheddar cheese.
Bacon Smoked Cheddar
$7.29
Our smoked cheddar with the addition of bacon.
Chili Pepper Cheddar
$6.99
Chili pepper cheddar is aged with chili peppers then rolled in extra peppers before packing.
Chipotle Cheddar
$7.29
Dusted in chipotle cheddar before packing, this is our cheesemaker’s favorite cheese.
Extra Sharp Cheddar
$7.57
Very distinctive, this yellow cheddar adds color and sharpness to any dish.
Garlic and Dill Cheddar Cheese
$4.99
This cheese combines roasted garlic and the fresh taste of dill weed with our honey brooke cheddar.
Honey Brook Medium Cheddar
$5.79
Hand waxed and aged approximately six months. Creamy with notes of cheddar sharpness.
Honey Brook Mild Cheddar
$5.79
Hand waxed and aged approximately three months. Creamy, mild, and distinctively farm fresh.
Honey Brook Sharp Cheddar
$5.99
Hand waxed and aged approximately one year. One of the most popular cheeses we sell.
Horseradish Bacon Cheddar
$7.06
Authentic maple cheddar naturally cold-smoked at the September farm.
Horseradish Cheddar
$6.49
In this cheese, we use fresh horseradish for a distinct, fresh taste.
Mango Fire Cheddar
$7.29
Maple Smoked Cheddar
$6.79
Authentic maple cheddar naturally cold-smoked at the September farm.
Muffaletta Cheddar
$7.06
This distinctive cheese is made with a blend of olives, garlic, and olive oil.
Robertson's Select Extra Sharp Cheddar
$6.99
Hand waxed and aged approximately two years.
Six-Year Extra Sharp Cheddar
$8.29
Super sharp, this cheese is an amazing treat for cheddar lovers.
Smoked Cheddar
$6.49
This cheese is especially for cheese lovers who like it smoked.
Symphony Cheddar Cheese
$8.29
An orchestra of flavor elements composed into a grand symphony. The result is a perfect harmony of sweet cheddar with notes of fruity parmesan and buttery gouda.
10-Year Cheddar
$8.49
Super sharp, this cheese is an amazing treat for cheddar lovers.
Cheese Curds
Bacon Horseradish Cheese Curds (8 oz)
$4.99
Bacon Smoked Cheese Curds (8 oz)
$4.99
Cajun Cheese Curds (8 oz)
$4.99
Garlic Dill Cheese Curds (8 oz)
$4.99
Harvest Ranch Cheese Curds (8 oz)
$4.99
One Pound Sack Original Cheese Curds (16 oz)
$6.99
Original Cheese Curds (8 oz)
$4.99
Wood-Fried Pizza Cheese Curds (8 oz)
$4.99
Cheese Spreads
Cheese Spread
$5.49
Chicken
Farmhouse Chicken Sandwich
$7.49
Served on a brioche roll with fried chicken, American cheese, mayonnaise, lettuce, tomato, and pickle.
Chicken Cheese Quesadilla
$8.29
This is our toasted chicken cheese quesadilla served with grilled chicken, plenty of cheese, black beans, salsa, sour cream, and lettuce.
Feta Chicken Berry Salad
$6.79
Served with grilled chicken, spinach, berries, feta cheese, and pecans.
Chicken Tenders
$5.79
This is our premium chicken tenders fried to perfection.
Coffee Beans (Snacks)
Coffee and Cream Espresso Beans
$4.39
Dark Chocolate Coffee Beans
$4.39
Milk Chocolate Covered Coffee Beans
$5.00
Tri-Colored Coffee Beans
$4.39
Coffee Coop
Biscotti
$2.19
Our fresh made biscotti is a great complement to a cup of coffee.
Creamy Freddo Brew
$2.79
September farms' own cold brew served over ice with caramel and your choice of creamer.
Iced Latte
$4.15
Our creamy espresso with steamed milk and your choice of syrup flavor served over ice.
Iced Spotted Mocha Latte
$4.15
A delicious blend of caramel and mocha syrup and espresso served over ice.
Iced Rooster call Cappuccino
$4.15
A decadent taste of honey, cinnamon, vanilla, and espresso served over ice.
Spotted Mocha Latte
$3.59
A delicious blend of caramel and mocha syrup and espresso.
Roaster Call Cappuccino
$3.35
A decadent taste of honey, cinnamon, vanilla, and espresso.
Drinks
Eureka Springs Bottled Water (16 oz)
$1.49
Gouda
Aged Gouda
$7.49
Authentic Dutch-style gouda aged to perfection in our cheese cave. Approximately 8 oz.
Baby Gouda
$7.49
This traditional Dutch-style baby gouda is a pleasantly young cheese. Approximately 8 oz.
Coconut Gouda
$7.49
This tropical cheese was inspired by the owner’s visit to a quaint cheese shop. Approximately 8 oz.
Smoked Gouda
$7.49
This cheese is smoked in-house and is always a customer favorite. Approximately 8 oz.
Granola (Bakery)
Honey Almond Granola (14 oz)
$5.99
Original Recipe Granola (14 oz)
$5.99
Sea Salt Caramel Granola (14 oz)
$5.99
Triple Treat Granola (14 oz)
$5.99
Kids Meals
Kids Chicken Tender Meal
$5.99
Three fried chicken tenders with a side of smiley fries.
Kids Hot Dog Meal
$4.79
A grilled hot dog served with a side of smiley fries.
Kids Toasted Cheese Meal
$5.99
A classic toasted cheese sandwich served with American cheese and a side of smiley fries.
Monterey Jack Cheese
Chives and Dill Jack
$5.99
This cheese is an award winner at the American cheese society and the pa. Cheesemaker’s competition.
Garlic and Basil Jack
$5.99
This cheese is a perfect complement to Italian dishes and makes a nice melt for meatball subs.
Habanero Jack
$6.79
The addition of habanero pepper makes this cheese super hot.
Harvest Jack
$5.99
This cheese will delight you with a unique blend of herb and vegetable flavors.
Honey Brook Jack
$5.79
Taste the freshness in this delicious, mild Monterey jack cheese.
Hot Pepper Jack
$9.99
The flavors of jalapeno and red pepper blend perfectly in this zesty cheese.
Joy's Tomato Basil Jack
$5.99
Sun-dried tomato and basil flavor this cheese bearing the name of the owner’s mother and daughter.
Jumpin' Jack Jalapeno
$5.99
Jalapenos make this fresh, creamy cheese a customer favorite.
Orange Cranberry Jack
$7.29
A light addition of cranberry and orange zest make this cheese a holiday star.
Pepperoni Augusto Jack
$5.99
With pizza ingredients like pepperoni and oregano, this is our most popular Monterey jack cheese.
Pizza Jack
$6.99
Light spice and pepperoni are added to this cheese along with hints of onion and red pepper.
Salsa Jack
$7.29
Laced with the flavors of onion, peppers, and tomatoes, this cheese compliments Mexican dishes.
Smoked Jalapeno Jack
$6.99
The unique combination of smokey flavor and jalapeno peppers makes this cheese a special treat.
Spring Onion Jack
$5.99
A lovely blend of chives and onion add delicate flavor to spring onion jack.
Other Cheeses
Amish Butter Cheese
$5.39
Farmer's Cheese
$2.65
Vegetable Farmer's Cheese
$3.00
Mozzarella Cheese
$5.49
Aged Swiss Cheese
$5.15
Baby Swiss Cheese
$5.15
Lacey Swiss Cheese
$5.15
Smoked Swiss Cheese
$5.15
Pasteries (Bakery)
Chocolate Chip Ricotta Cookies (6 pcs)
$7.14
Four Pack Muffin
$7.99
Four varieties of large and soft muffins packaged in a fun box.
Honey Lavender Shortbread Cookies
$3.09
Original Cheese Tarts (4 pack)
$9.16
Our Famous Whoopie Pies (6 pack)
$11.94
Six whoopie pies filled with homemade vanilla frosting.
Peanut Butter Whoopie Pies (6 pack)
$11.94
Six whoopie pies with sweet peanut butter filling.
Walnut Creek Cinnamon Roll Maple Icing (Single)
$3.29
Pretzels (Snacks)
Honey Mustard Pretzels
$2.25
Martin's pretzels (8 oz)
$3.99
SFC Honey Mustard and Onion Pretzels
$3.49
SFC Lemon Pepper and Dill Pretzels
$3.49
SFC Sweet Cheddar Pretzels
$3.49
Quesadillas
Cheese Quesadilla
$6.99
This is our toasted cheese quesadilla served with plenty of cheese, salsa, sour cream, and lettuce.
Chicken Cheese Quesadilla
$8.29
This is our toasted chicken cheese quesadilla served with grilled chicken, plenty of cheese, black beans, salsa, sour cream, and lettuce.
Salads
Chef Salad
$6.79
Served with ham, turkey, spring mix, red egg, peppers, and tomatoes.
Festive Salad
$6.79
Served with grilled chicken, spring mix, three-cheese blend, craisins, and pecans.
Feta Chicken Berry Salad
$6.79
Served with grilled chicken, spinach, berries, feta cheese, and pecans.
Southwest Salad
$6.79
Served with grilled chicken, corn, black beans, tomatoes, and tortilla strips.
Sides
Creamy Tomato Soup
$3.99
Our creamy tomato soup in a cup or a bowl
Fried Cheese Curds
$3.99
Our fresh-made cheddar cheese curds lightly breaded and fried to perfection.
French Fries
$3.29
Our signature french fries fried to perfection.
Cheese French Fries
$3.79
Our signature french fries fried to perfection covered in cheese.
Macaroni and Cheese
$3.99
Macaroni and cheese in a cup or a bowl.
Mac and Cheese Bites
$4.29
Mac and cheese breaded and fried to perfection.
Chicken Tenders
$5.79
This is our premium chicken tenders fried to perfection.
Fried Onion Rings
$3.79
Our signature onion rings fried to perfection.
Fried Pickle Spears
$4.69
Fried pickle spears fried to perfection.
Smoked Meats (Snacks)
Seltzers Lebanon Bologna Club
$4.49
This bologna is a great partner for any cheese. Choose from two sizes.
Seltzers Sweet Lebanon Bologna Chub
$4.49
This bologna is a great partner for any cheese. Choose from two sizes.
Stoltzfus Ring Bologna (18 oz)
$6.95
A great party food when sliced and served with your favorite cheese.
Sweet Bologna Snack Sticks with Cheese (12 oz)
$9.35
These sticks are great for snacking or packing in lunch.
Toasted Cheese Sandwiches
Mary's Melt Sandwich
$7.59
This is our toasted mary’s melt sandwich served on gluten-free bread with lactose-free yogurt cheese, turkey, and dairy-free honey mustard.
The Robertson Toasted Sandwich
$8.29
This is our toasted Robertson served on sourdough bread with Robertson's sharp cheddar, rotisserie chicken, mushrooms, spinach, and black pepper mayonnaise.
