Our cookie cake slice designs change weekly. The slice will always have some buttercream icing on them but may not be covered completely with buttercream icing.
Round Nutter Butter cookies covered in white chocolate. Price is for one large individual.
Gooey Pop
$3.25
Gooey pops are our delicious gooeys covered in white or dark chocolate on a stick. Please check the box for the flavor you want. The flavor of pops we make changes daily so we may not always have the flavor you want. You can call the store first at 722-5247 to see what flavors are available at the time of purchase. If you order a flavor we don't have in stock, we will give you a different flavor.
Mini Chocolate Covered Oreos
$7.50
Mini Oreos covered in milk chocolate. 12 in a bag.
Chocolate Covered Oreos in 3 Pack
$6.50
The pack includes one milk chocolate covered double stuffed Oreo, one white chocolate covered double stuffed Oreo and one white chocolate covered Nutter Butter.
Chocolate Covered Oreos
$2.25
Double stuffed Oreo cookies covered in milk chocolate. Price is for one large individual cookie.
Gluten Free Oreos
$8.50
Pack of three large double stuffed Gluten Free Oreos covered in milk chocolate with drizzle and sprinkles.
Drinks
Starbucks Frappuccino
$3.50
9.5 ounce bottle. Choose from Mocha, Vanilla or Caramel flavors.
Coke
$2.50
16.9 ounces. Plastic bottle.
Dr. Pepper
$2.50
16.9 ounces. Plastic bottle.
Mountain Dew
$2.50
16.9 ounces. Plastic bottle.
Sprite
$2.50
16.9 ounces. Plastic bottle.
Whimsy Water
$2.50
16.9 ounces.
Diet Mountain Dew
$2.50
Glass Bottle Coke
$2.50
12 ounces.
Diet Dr Pepper
$2.50
Pepsi
$2.50
The bold, refreshing, robust cola.
Diet Pepsi
$2.50
A crisp tasting, refreshing pop of sweet, fizzy bubbles without calories.
Minute Maid Lemonade
$2.50
IBC Root Beer in Glass Bottle
$2.50
Diet Coke
$2.50
16.9 ounces. Plastic bottle.
Pepsi Wild Cherry
$2.50
Chocolate Milk
$3.00
12 ounces.
White Milk
$3.00
12 ounces.
Arnold Palmer Tea/Lemonade
$2.50
Coca Cola Zero Sugar
$2.50
Platter
Platter with Cellophane Wrap and Bow
$4.00
We will put your cookies on a clear platter with shredded paper and wrap it all in cellophane with a large bow. This makes a nice presentation when gifting.
Enclosure Card
$0.50
This can be used if you would like us to write a note to the recipient for you.
Platter with Saran Wrap
$3.00
We will put your cookies on a clear platter with shredded paper and cover it all with saran wrap to help cookies stay fresh and to help the cookies stay in place for traveling.
Specialty Cookies
Chocolate Chip Buttercream Sandwich with Sprinkles
$4.50
Two chocolate chip cookies with buttercream in the middle and sprinkles. Price is per cookie.
Chocolate Chip Cookie Stuffed with Oreo
$3.00
Our classic chocolate chip cookie with a double stuffed Oreo baked in the middle! Price is per cookie.
Peanut Butter Cookie
$2.25
Our delicious peanut butter cookies are rolled in sugar and baked to perfection. Soft on the inside and a little crunchy on the outside.
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$2.50
Our classic chocolate chip cookie. Price is per cookie.
Chocolate Covered Pretzel Rods
$4.25
Three long pretzel rods will be covered in either milk chocolate, dark chocolate or white chocolate and sprinkles depending on what we have in the store. They come in a clear bag with a bow.
Snickerdoodles
$2.25
Our delicious snickerdoodle cookies are rolled in cinnamon and sugar and baked to perfection!
Oatmeal Classic Cookie
$2.25
A soft oatmeal cookie without raisins. Price is per cookie.
Chocolate Chip M&M Cookie
$2.75
Our Classic Chocolate Chip cookie with M&Ms added in for extra goodness!
Chocolate Sugar Buttercream Sandwich
$4.50
Two chocolate sugar cookies with sugar crystals baked in with buttercream in the middle. Price is per cookie.
Gooey Pops
$3.50
Our popular gooeys covered in white or dark chocolate on a stick. You may request which flavor you would like from the list, but if we are out of that flavor, we will substitute another flavor. If you definitely don't want a particular flavor, be sure and let us know in the comments.
Oatmeal Cream Pie
$3.85
Two of our classic oatmeal cookies with marshmallow cream. Way better than a Little Debbie! Price is per cookie.
Buttercream Rosette
$3.85
Our sugar cookie with buttercream and sprinkles on top. Price is per cookie.
Brownie with Buttercream
$3.75
Our fudgy brownie topped with buttercream and sprinkles! Oh, so rich and delicious!
Macadamia Nut Cookie
$3.25
Sugar Cookies
Detailed Sugar Cookies
$4.50
Our classic Whimsy sugar cookie with a medium amount of detailing involved. Example: diamonds with glitter, dinosaurs, butterflies.
Extra Detailed Sugar Cookies
$5.00
Our classic Whimsy sugar cookie decorated with extra detailing. Example: unicorns with gold, Happy Birthday written and sprinkles.
Gluten Free Sugar Cookie
$4.50
Our classic Whimsy sugar cookie with minimum detailing involved but baked with rice flour instead of wheat flour. Each cookie comes heat sealed.
Basic Decorated Cookies
$4.00
Our classic Whimsy sugar cookie with minimum detailing involved. Example: smiley faces or swirls.
Buttercream Rosette
$3.85
Our sugar cookie with buttercream and sprinkles on top. Price is per cookie.
Whimsy Cookie Bites
Whimsy Sugar Cookie Bites
$10.00
Our classic Whimsy sugar cookie but bite sized. (1-1. 5") 12 to a bag.
Whimsy Gooey Butter Cookies and Gooey Pops
Gooey Pops
$3.50
Our famous gooeys covered in white or dark chocolate on a stick. You may request which flavor you would like from the list, but if we are out of that flavor, we will substitute another flavor. If you definitely don't want a particular flavor, be sure and let us know in the comments.
Gooey Cookies
$2.50
Please check the box for only the flavor you want. If you check more boxes than the quantity you are ordering, you may end up paying more.
Buttercream Gooey Cookies
$4.25
We can put buttercream on any gooey flavor so only pick the flavor that you would like. If you check more than one flavor at a time, you may end up paying more.
Mini Gooey Cookies
$5.50
When ordering this item, you will be receiving the four gooey minis that were baked that day. This will include four of one of the butter, strawberry, lemon, red velvet, chocolate or birthday cake gooeys. These come bagged and tied ready for eating or gifting.
