Top Italian Restaurants in Bayville

Gino’s Of East Norwich

Bayville, NY

4.9

(77 reviews)

Tre Sorelle Ristorante

Bayville, NY

4.9

(34 reviews)

Josies Pizza Bar

Bayville, NY

4.8

(23 reviews)

La Bottega Glen Cove

Bayville, NY

4.8

(260 reviews)

Mario's Pizzeria (Oyster Bay)

Bayville, NY

4.8

(1,000 reviews)

Messina Market & Catering

Bayville, NY

4.7

(260 reviews)

Umberto's Oyster Bay

Bayville, NY

4.7

(700 reviews)

Villa Meci Pizzeria

Bayville, NY

4.7

(700 reviews)

La Famiglia Pizzeria & Restaurant

Bayville, NY

4.6

(360 reviews)

Mama Mia’s Pizza and Pasta

Bayville, NY

4.6

(72 reviews)

Umberto's Of Glen Cove

Bayville, NY

4.6

(180 reviews)

Stellina Cafe & Bakery

Bayville, NY

4.5

(86 reviews)