Top Italian Restaurants in New York

La Scala Restaurant & Pizzeria

Central Islip, NY

4.6

(1,500 reviews)

Mario’s Pizzeria (East Northport)

Centerport, NY

4.6

(1,000 reviews)

Seacove Italian American Bar & Grill

Center Moriches, NY

4.6

(500 reviews)

Pizza Hut (534 William Floyd Parkway)

Center Moriches, NY

4.6

(500 reviews)

Mary's Pizza and Pasta

Center Moriches, NY

4.6

(90 reviews)

Bonillas Pizza

Brightwaters, NY

4.6

(360 reviews)

Patrizia's of Long Island (Hauppauge)

Brightwaters, NY

4.6

(1,500 reviews)

Casaletto Restaurant

Briarcliff Manor, NY

4.6

(500 reviews)

Gino's of Nesconset

Bohemia, NY

4.6

(700 reviews)

Umberto's of Sayville

Blue Point, NY

4.6

(900 reviews)

Capri Pizza & Pasta

Blauvelt, NY

4.6

(1,500 reviews)

Papa Tino's Pizzeria

Black River, NY

4.6

(28 reviews)