Top Italian Restaurants in New York

Thornwood Pizza & Pasta

Armonk, NY

4.6

(430 reviews)

Craft Pizza & Beer

Armonk, NY

4.6

(290 reviews)

Wood And Fire - Pleasantville

Armonk, NY

4.6

(2,000 reviews)

No Image

Il Bacio Trattoria

Ardsley, NY

4.6

(1,000 reviews)

No Image

Gino's Pizza of West Babylon

Amityville, NY

4.6

(1,000 reviews)

No Image

Umberto's of Massapequa Park

Amityville, NY

4.6

(900 reviews)

No Image

Cara Mia

Amityville, NY

4.6

(500 reviews)

No Image

Villa Italian Specialties

Amagansett, NY

4.6

(800 reviews)

No Image

Pepperoni's

Amagansett, NY

4.6

(490 reviews)

No Image

Umberto's of New Hyde Park

Albertson, NY

4.6

(4,000 reviews)

No Image

Mario's Pizza (Westbury)

Albertson, NY

4.6

(1,000 reviews)

Villa Formia - Oceanside

East Atlantic Beach, NY

4.5

(500 reviews)