Top Italian Restaurants in New York

Americano Pie Bar

Bay Shore, NY

4.6

(1,000 reviews)

Vinnies Mulberry Street Pizzeria

Bay Shore, NY

4.6

(600 reviews)

Brooklyn Calzones (99 West Ave)

Ballston Spa, NY

4.6

(13 reviews)

Empire Pizza (S Broadway)

Ballston Spa, NY

4.6

(100 reviews)

Domino's (86 Washington St)

Ballston Spa, NY

4.6

(110 reviews)

Sergio's Pizza - Riverhead

Baiting Hollow, NY

4.6

(1,000 reviews)

Wading River Pizzeria

Baiting Hollow, NY

4.6

(62 reviews)

Papa Johns Pizza (1840 Deer Park Avenue)

Babylon, NY

4.6

(3,000 reviews)

Domino's (# A, 111 W Sunrise Hwy)

Babylon, NY

4.6

(340 reviews)

Hawthorne Pizzeria

Armonk, NY

4.6

(270 reviews)

Vinnie’s Pizza & Pasta

Armonk, NY

4.6

(100 reviews)

Gianfranco Pizzeria & Restaurant

Armonk, NY

4.6

(450 reviews)