Top Italian Restaurants in New York

Gemelli Pizzeria

Bronxville, NY

4.7

(3,000 reviews)

Our Little Italy

Brightwaters, NY

4.7

(1,500 reviews)

Richie's Pizza

Brightwaters, NY

4.7

(600 reviews)

La Slice Pizzeria

Bohemia, NY

4.7

(1,500 reviews)

The Pizzeria of Islip

Bohemia, NY

4.7

(1,500 reviews)

Dragos Pizza

Blue Point, NY

4.7

(170 reviews)

Joe's Pizza & Pasta

Blue Point, NY

4.7

(2,000 reviews)

The Pizzeria of Bayport

Blue Point, NY

4.7

(1,000 reviews)

Leonardo's Italian Deli & Catering

Blauvelt, NY

4.7

(460 reviews)

Three Boys From Italy

Blauvelt, NY

4.7

(900 reviews)

Divino Cucina Italiana

Blauvelt, NY

4.7

(200 reviews)

One Pie Pizza

Blasdell, NY

4.7

(82 reviews)